The real immigration action started off with Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.).
Above is a picture of the scattered standing ovation he received when he took the podium (I’d say about 5 percent stood, the rest applauded happily, but not wildly).
The content of the speech was nothing too surprising:
* End birthright citizenship
* Build a wall
“Open borders are wrong," Tancredo said. “No matter how good they are for the restaurant industry.”
Yes, God forbid the restaurant industry, the construction industry, fruit growers or any other industry do well.
So, here’s the rub with all the people who think that immigration is going to be the defining issue within the Republican Party for years to come. They’re wrong — and not just because their policies are based on economic ignorance and not-so-subtle racism.
Why? Because the modern Republican Party doesn’t work without a decent segment of the Hispanic vote. The party George W. Bush has built will lose if it morphs (back) into the old Republican Party that wants to keep brown people out.
The numbers don’t work. (And, well, the economy would fall apart if any of the anti-immigration folks got their way … but that’s another set of numbers.)
“It is the president who is out of step with his party, not Tom Tancredo," says Tancredo. That may be true with a certain segment of the GOP base. But presidents win in the center to the extent they restrain the ugliest impulses of their bases. Bush may be out of step with some conservative activists, but he’s in step with the American people.
As for things Tancredo said that I agreed with…
He did have some nice stuff to say about how George W. Bush has corrupted the Republican Party.
“We are not the party of bigger government," he said. And he said the GOP should admit its mistakes by repealing the Medicare prescription-drug bill and No Child Left Behind.
He’s right about all that, of course. But that’s the problem with expanding government. Once it’s done, it’s done. Neither of those programs can ever be repealed now (though NCLB could be reformed into somewhat decent shape, if you brought back the voucher provisions that were stripped out immediately when Congress took it up in 2001).
Oddest moment: "God bless Denmark," Tancredo declared, as an aside. There was some enthusiastic spontaneous applause … though not as much as for ending birthright citizenship.
Recent Comments