The Bingo Bob Court

My most recent Tech Central Station column takes a closer look at the question of questioning Supreme Court nominees:

Sure, Roberts is not quite “mediocre.” It’s hard to call a guy with his resume mediocre. But after a week of every liberal interest group in the country digging around in the judge’s past like a bunch of coked-up ferrets for his positions on various issues, we’ve learned … precisely nothing.

This nominee’s not just stealth. He’s actually invisible.

But while the Roberts nomination may seem like a sly move to a White House that clearly sees itself in a weak position politically, is this the kind of behavior anyone wants to encourage in a president? Is this any kind of process, where a nominee to the Supreme Court having an opinion on anything — like, say, the Constitution — is seen as a potentially devastating liability?

It’s been an interesting debate, and I’ve been encouraged to see some conservatives I trust come out on the side of serious questioning (Ponnuru, Barnett and some other folks at Bench Memos).

Sen. Schumer’s general grandstanding and dumbassitude has made it a harder debate to have within the conservative movement (though I don’t think we’d be having the debate at all if not for his agitation). But it’s starting to proceed.

It probably won’t affect the process for this nomination, which is basically a lock. But it could make people think a bit harder in the future.

Or, Roberts will sail through so easily — precisely because of the “stealth” strategy — that a dangerous precedent will be set for decades to come.

Could go either way, I guess.

Oh well.

1 Response to “The Bingo Bob Court”


  1. 1 Mark Tapscott Jul 29th, 2005 at 9:15 pm

    It is indeed a debate that is needed on the Right and is part of a more general debate that is more needed on the importance of transparency in government, strengthening the Freedom of Information Act (as proposed by Cornyn and Leahy) and routinely putting government contracts and other documents on the Internet for public examination.

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.




 

Ryan Sager's Email List

Name:
Email:
Subscribe  Unsubscribe