Well, it’s no secret that immigration is a big point of contention in the conservative movement.
It shouldn’t be. And thank God Bush is on the right side.
I say it shouldn’t be because of just how antithetical everything the anti-immigration folks say is to the American and Republican philosophies.
My jaw was honestly on the floor listening to the following Phyllis Schlafly quotes:
“The idea of giving any job to any willing worker is absolutely unacceptable.”
“The idea of offering a job to any willing worker is so offensive.”
“Americans won’t work for these wages… companies need to pay more.”
These quotes, I assure you, are not in any way out of context. This woman is actually righteously offended that Americans should have to work for the wage the market sets for their labor.
This is how far we’ve come as conservatives, that our leaders will passionately defend the minimum wage — a hugely destructive, intrusive government regulation.
Schlafly, amazingly enough, also blamed unemployed software engineers on illegal immigration. Now, first off, I haven’t heard anything about a huge herd of unemployed software engineers. If there is any such phenomenon, look to the dot-com crash as to blame. Second, WHAT!?!?!? Does she think that software engineers are sneaking in illegally from India to take American jobs?
After Schlafly talked, Tamar Jacoby of the Manhattan Institute came up to the dais to defend President Bush’s guest-worker proposal. She was booed loudly.
“That’s really polite,” Tamar responded.
She went on to give a fiery speech to scattered applause. Basically, she argued that our current immigration laws invite disrespect because they’re unrealistically strict. In the Q&A, she used a good metaphor. She said our current laws were like a 20 MPH speed limit on the freeway. How many cops would it take to enforce that? How many people would observe it?
Roy Beck of Numbers USA gave the most outlandish speech. I’ll just give you the nice, outrageous quotes:
“Too many of our elected leaders think illegal immigration is a victimless crime.”
“Illegal immigrants are similar to most burglars.”
“Illegal aliens are wage thieves. They steal our jobs.”
Actually, one more thing about Beck. He made one really revealing comment. He said that he actually is not in favor of massive deportation of illegal immigrants. Why? Because it would cause a huge economic displacement — and thus a huge backlash among the American public against the crackdown on illegal immigration.
Instead, Beck supports a very gradual crackdown — apparently so that Americans won’t realize what’s happening. But won’t that just damage the economy in slow motion?
Sounds an awful lot like it.
Of course, Stephen Moore made the important political point: Bush won, to some extent, by getting better Hispanic support than other Republicans. Can we expect to succeed as a party if we tell Hispanics that we don’t want more people like them coming to our country?
Hmmmmmmm… Let’s see… No, we can’t.
Recent Comments